Thursday, January 29, 2026

2026 - My Breakthrough Moment

James Roberson 1773-1815 – Howard’s 4th Great-Grandfather

For more than 30 years, I had been searching for the origins of James Roberson, my husband’s 4th great grandfather. I knew James was born about 1775 in South Carolina, that he married Martha Davis, and that they had three children before moving to Giles County, Tennessee. A probate record in Giles County confirmed that James had died and Martha was his widow, but nothing pointed clearly to James’s father or siblings.

Giles County, Tennessee Probate Record 1815
Estate of James Robertson

In South Carolina, I found tantalizing clues—deeds in Laurens County involving a John Robertson and a Basil Robertson, including one where John sold land to a James O. Robertson. I suspected a connection, but without documentation, it remained only a hypothesis. Census records placed Basil in Warren County, Kentucky, and James in Giles County, Tennessee, but the relationship between them was still a mystery.

Deed Records - Laurens County, South Carolina
James Odell Robertson / John Robertson / Martha Robertson

I even traveled to Bowling Green, Kentucky, to research at Western Kentucky University. A librarian there, who happened to be a descendant of Basil Robertson, believed our families were connected, but neither of us could prove how. Later, a Y-DNA match from a gentleman in Texas strengthened the case that my husband’s line was tied to Basil’s family. Still, the exact relationship eluded me. I began to think Basil might be James’s brother, with John Robertson of Laurens County as their father.

And then came the moment that changed everything.

One day, I opened FamilySearch to review Basil’s profile, hoping to find a deed linking him to South Carolina or Kentucky. Instead, I found something entirely unexpected: a probate record for a Basil Robertson of Warren County, Kentucky, born in 1745 and died in 1831. Not just one record—several. His children had contested his will, and the estate took nearly twelve years to settle. The documents revealed disputes over the sale of enslaved people and disagreements with the executor, one of Basil’s sons.

The probate papers listed all of Basil’s children—and among them was a son named James Robertson, married to a Martha, with all their children named as heirs.

Warren County, Kenntucky - Chancery Court Record - Heirs of Basil Roberson 
Martha Roberson, widow of James Roberson deceased, John, James, Reginal "Nig", Henry, Bazel & Nathan, sons of James Roberson deceased. Nancy, Elizabeth & Martha, Eleanor, daughters of James Roberson deceased.

-

There it was. After decades of searching, the answer had been waiting in a probate packet in Warren County, Kentucky. James wasn’t Basil’s brother—he was Basil’s son.

I sat there stunned. After thirty years of piecing together clues, chasing records across states, studying deeds, census entries, and DNA matches, the truth finally emerged from a single set of probate documents. It was my breakthrough moment—one I wish I could have shared with my motherinlaw, my research partner and fellow Roberson detective. She would have been thrilled to know that together, we had pushed the Roberson line back one more generation, all the way to Basil Robertson, my husband’s 5th great grandfather.

Basil Roberson was born about 1749, likely in the Carolinas. Around 1770 he married Mary Ellen—her surname still unknown—and together they raised a large family of eleven children. Their first son, James Odell Roberson, arrived about 1773, and their youngest was born in 1790. Basil served his country during the Revolutionary War, fighting in 1781–1782 in the South Carolina Cavalry under Colonel Maham at the Ninety-Six District garrison. Sometime in the early 1800s Basil moved to Hardcastle, Warren County, Kentucky where he died in 1831 and several of his decendants still live. 

Children of James & Martha (Davis) Roberson 
As listed in Warren County, Kentucky Chancery Court Records







No comments:

Post a Comment