Tuesday, February 25, 2020

2020 Prompt - Prosperity - Denis Cronin


                                                       



Prompt - Prosperity

Denis Cronin- great grandfather


Nancy Simmons to Josephine Martin to Mary Catherine Cronin to Denis Cronin - my great grandfather 


I thought of my great grandfather, Denis Cronin, when the prompt Prosperity was assigned. Prosperity usually means the type of success that comes from having a lot of money. But "a lot of money" is relative to how much you had to start with in life.  Denis left Ireland a poor 17-year-old boy and followed his siblings to Detroit with a dream of prosperity.

  

I used Denis’ death certificate to start researching him. Denis died in Sunland, Los Angeles, California Dec 21, 1925[1] at the home of his brother, Daniel Cronin. His death certificate stated he was 66 years old, born in Ireland and his parents were John Cronin and Johanna O'Connor. 




Denis was born in Ireland to parents that had survived the great famine. They had ten children and Denis was the 3rd child born in County Cork where years of political and religious dissention were prevalent.  In the mid-1870s widespread unemployment, poverty and appalling housing conditions existed.[2]



In 1877,[3] Denis decided to leave Ireland and move to Detroit, Michigan where he found work in a thriving industrial city. He married and raised a family of six children. He went from a poor Irish boy from Coolinarna, County Cork, Ireland[4] to a successful streetcar engineer and a leader among his peers.  He came to a country where he started working in a dangerous entry level job, was able to move up the ladder of prosperity due to his involvement in unionizing the streetcar employees and could practice his faith without conflict.




His baptismal record had his name is recorded as Dionysius Cronin.  He was baptized 16 Oct 1859 in the Catholic Parish of Cullen in Millstreet, County Cork, Ireland[5]. Dionysius is the Latin derivative of Denis used in the Catholic church records. Cullen is a small village located north west of Millstreet town in County Cork[6].




 
Denis' passport application states he immigrated in 1877. Many poor Irish immigrants could find work in Detroit in high risk occupations. He found work as a molder at the Peninsular Stove Company by 1882.[7]  This risky job earned between $18 and $21 per week[8]. (Footnote has website about Detroit as global capital of stove manufacturing).  A molder was a strong young male who worked in a dark, hellish environment with enormous cupola furnaces filled with hot blue smoke and pounds of glowing cherry-red molten iron.  The molder would be covered with black grime and soot and poor hot molten iron into molds.[9] Life as a molder was dangerous and harmful and over time molders often suffered from lung and heart problems.


 On June 2, 1886, Denis Cronin married Bridget Stackpoole[10],a young Irish immigrant. The same

year, Denis is listed as a car inspector and his home is at 175 Franklin Street.[11] Denis had found a job working as an inspector for a streetcar company. This job is probably much safer than a molder now that he is married.





In April 1891, Denis is working for the Detroit Urban Railway and is now a driver. He probably was caught up in the political aspect of labor unrest as the streetcar employees decided to strike.[12] Even though we have no record of Denis' direct involvement in this conflict, one wonders if he reported to work and drove his streetcar, or did he withhold his services and joined the strikers?


A month later in May of 1891, Denis profits from an agreement between owners and the workers.  The agreement gives conductors and drivers an 18 cent per hour wage with a 10-hour workday and one day off every 14 days.[13] This gives Denis a $46.00 a month paycheck or about $600 annual income.  





In the 1900 federal census, Denis is listed as a motorman with the street railroad, he can read and write, and he owns his home.[14] This illustrates that Denis is doing quite well working for the street rail system.  Denis and Bridget also have five children by 1900; Johanna is 13, Dennis is nine, Margaret is seven, my grandmother Mary Catherine is four, and William is two. They lost a two-year-old son in 1891.[15]



In 1906 Denis Cronin was very active in the street railway employee union since he runs for president of the streetcar employee’s union.[16]  Over 1100 workers voted but unfortunately Denis comes in second by 210 votes. [17]




Another event that occurs in 1909 that affirms Denis' growing prosperity was his ability to take a trip with his wife and young daughter to Ireland to visit his family. Denis applies for a passport and provides us with lots of personal information. In 1910 we find that Denis bought a second home at 719 Campbell street by auction for $3,300[18] and he moves from 211 Nineteenth Street to his new home.





In 1920 the census states Denis is still working as a motorman, lives at 719 Campbell street.[19]  Sometime after 1920 Denis retires and then on November 30, 1924 Denis' wife, Bridget, died.[20]  A year later, Denis decided to travel to Los Angeles to visit his brother, Daniel.  It is while he is in California that he died on December 21, 1925.[21]  His body is shipped back to Detroit and he is buried in Mt Elliott Cemetery next to his wife. According to my mother, when Denis died, he left a house for each of his children. 





Denis’ prosperity was measured by his ability to find work to earn a good wage, and his participation in a union to advocate for safe working conditions and a fair wage for all.  By working hard and investing he was able to purchase several homes to help his children.  And during his 48 years in Detroit, Denis and his family were able to practice their faith without conflict. He was an example of how an immigrant can attain prosperity!













[1]Denis Cronin, death certificate Local Registered No. 194 (died 21 Dec 1925), Department of Public Health, San Francisco City and County, California.  
[2] Cork City Council, Cork City Libraries, Grand Parade, Cork, Ireland, Cork, Past and Present, accessed: 19 Feb 2020, http://www.corkpastandpresent.ie/history/historyofcorkcity/1700-1900/corkinthe19thcentury/
[3] Ancestry.com, U.S. Passport Applications, 1795-1925, Dennis Cronin, certificate 10227.
[4] Ancestry.com, Ireland, Catholic Parish Registers, 1655-1915, Dionysius Cronin, residence: Coolnarna.
[5] Ibid.
[7] Ancestry.com, U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989 accessed: 20 Feb 2020, page 317, Dennis Cronin; citing "Detroit, Michigan, City Directory, 1882.
[9] “When stoves were the hot new thing”, The Detroit News, 24 Jan 2015, accessed: 20 Feb 2020, <https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/michigan-history/2015/01/24/stove-capital-detroit-history/22234051/>
[10] Ancestry.Com, Michigan, County Marriages, 1822-1940, Denis Cranin (misspelled Cronin).
[11] Ancestry.com, U.S. City Directories, 1821-1989", accessed: 20 Feb 2020, page 429, Dennis Cronin; citing "Detroit, Michigan, City Directory, 1886.
[12] Detroit Transit History.info, The Pre-D.S.R. Years- Part II, Labor Unrest.  http://www.detroittransithistory.info/TheEarlyYears.html
[13] Ibid
[14] Ancestry.com, 1900 United States Federal Census, Detroit Ward 10, Wayne, Michigan, page: 10B; ED 107, Dennis Cronin, accessed: 13 May 2010.
[15] Ancestry.com, Michigan, Death Records, 1867-1950, John Daniel Cronin.
[16] 'Street Car Men Elect', The Detroit Free Press, 5 Dec 1906, Wed, p. 8; image copy, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/clip/3482663/denis-cronin-runs-for-president-of/)
[17] Ibid
[18] Denis Cronin house purchase, The Detroit Free Press, 18 Sep 1910, Sun, p.44; image copy, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/clip/45178589/dennis-cronin-house-purchase-719/)
[19] Ancestry.com, 1920 United States Federal Census, Detroit, Ward 16, Wayne, Michigan, page 5A, ED 495, Dennis Cronin, accessed: 13 May 2010.
[20]  Ancestry.com, Michigan, Death Records, 1867-1952, Bridget Enzian (misspelled Cronin), accessed 20 Feb 2020.
[21] Denis Cronin, death certificate Local Registered No. 194 (died 21 Dec 1925), Department of Public Health, San Francisco City and County, California.  

Tuesday, February 18, 2020

2020 Prompt - Favorite Discovery - Ernest Wentworth Putman


Ancestor - Ernest Wentworth Putman born 1875 – great grandfather
Nancy to Paul Simmons to June Elizabeth Putman to Ernest W Putman to Perry WILLEY


Ernest W Putman @1884
My “Favorite Discovery” would have to be finding my great grandfather, Ernest Putman’s, father using DNA matches.  I had already established that Ernest’s mother was Mary Ellen Putman born in 1857 daughter to Joseph and Elizabeth Putman.

On August 8th, 2018, I found a match for a 4th cousin on Ancestry DNA and it was M.R. and a small tree1 was posted.  I needed to research this tree, find a family that was living in Vermilion County, Illinois near the birthplace of Ernest Putman and find a young man of the age to be Ernie’s father.

I started with M.R.’s father, Ralph Pearlean WILLEY, and was able to find his death certificate that stated he was born in 1900 in Missouri and his parents were Abe WILLEY and Lavinia Baker.2 

I researched Abe, Abraham WILLEY, and found his death certificate.3 He was born in Missouri in 1877 and his parents were Joseph WILLEY and Elizabeth Miller. The family had pretty-well settled in Missouri up to this time but where did Joseph WILLEY live before Missouri?

Joseph Andrew WILLEY appeared as born in 1833 in Ohio and his parents were listed as George W WILLEY and Minerva Tilleson.4  When I found Joseph WILLEY's death certificate, his date of birth was listed as 28 December 1833 born in Ohio.  But also listed in the Ancestry search was a family tree with Joseph WILLEY and his brother Hugh WILLEY born in Potomac, Vermilion County, Illinois.5   BINGO!  The same location as the Putman family. 

I decided to search the 1860 census for any WILLEY living in Vermilion County, Illinois. Hugh B Willey was the oldest one listed in Vermilion County, Illinois so I checked him out first.  Where did he live in Vermilion County? 

In the 1860 Ross Township, Vermilion County, Illinois, Federal Census H B WILLEY is 31 years old and his wife Sarah is 31 years old and children; Jane is 10, William is 8, Perry is 4.6  Hugh is also listed in the 1870 census and the 1880 federal census in Vermilion County. 

I find Hugh B WILLEY on the same page and only four residence away from Joseph PUTMAN who is 60 years old and wife Elizabeth. They are Ernie’s grandparents. BINGO!! 

Since Ernest was born in October 1875, did the Hugh Willey family have any sons that could possibly be Ernest’s father?  The 1870 Rossville, Ross Township, Vermilion County, Illinois federal census8 list Hugh WILLEY and Sarah WILLEY with their children: Jane is 20, William 17, Perry 14 and John 10.  William married in 1873, Perry would have just turned 18 in Nov 1874 and didn’t marry till 1879 and John died in April 1873 at age 12. Could Perry WILLEY possibly be Ernest Putman’s father?

1870 Vermilion County Census Hugh & Sarah WILLEY


Based on the DNA evidence and the census records in Vermilion County, Illinois, Perry Willey looks like the most obvious candidate for the father of Ernest W. Putman. In January 1875 Perry was 18 years old when Ernest would have been conceived.  Mary Ellen Putman had just turned 17 years old on December 27, 1874.

The 1875 Vermilion County plot map9 displays the Willey Farm one farm away from Joseph Putman's farm.  So, we have the Hugh Willey family living very close to Joseph Putman's family with daughter, Mary Ellen Putman who would be 17 and her neighbor Perry Willey 18 living nearby with his parents.


In conclusion, based on the evidence of many Ancestry autosomal DNA matches and the evidence found in federal census records and a property map of Vermilion County, Illinois, there is a strong indication that Perry Willey is the father of Ernest Putman.  This discovery reveals the family of my great-great grandfather Perry WILLEY and fills a gap I have had in my family tree. 



Nancy's DNA match to MR 
George W WILLEY - Common Ancestor

1 Ancestry DNA Results for Nancy Simmons Roberson,” database report, AncestryDNA, (dna.ancestry.com/matches: accessed 22 July 2018), predicted 4th cousin match for Nancy Simmons Roberson and M.R. sharing 49 cMs DNA; documented relationship 3C2XR. 
2 Missouri, Death Certificates, 1910-1962, Ralph P Willey, # S1-029940, accessed 3 Sep 2018, Ancestry.
3 Missouri, Death Certificates, 1910-1962, Abe Lewis Willey, # 14816, accessed 3 Sep 2018, Ancestry.
4 Missouri, Death Certificates, 1910-1962, Joseph A Willey, # 38022, accessed 3 Sep 2018, Ancestry 5 John Fuqua Family Tree, Ancestry.com, https://www.ancestry.com/familytree/person/tree/86106926/person/42532665684/facts, subscription database, accessed Sep 2018. 
6 1860 United States Federal Census, household of H.B. Willey, Ross Twp., Vermilion Co., IL, Page 287, family dwelling 1996, Ancestry 
7 1880 United States Federal Census, household of Willey Hugh B, Ross Twp., Vermilion Co., IL, ED 221, Page 10, family dwelling 86, household of Willey William, family dwelling 90 and household of Putman Joseph, family dwelling 92, Ancestry
8 1870 United States Federal Census, household of Willey Hugh B, Ross Twp., Vermilion Co., IL, Page 8, family dwelling 48, Ancestry 
9 Historical Atlas Map, Vermilion County, Illinois, W.R. Brink & Co, 1875, Danville Public Library.